Brain size, intelligence and meat consumption- The vegan argument
Written By: Milos Pokimica
Medically Reviewed by: Dr. Xiùying Wáng, M.D.
Updated June 9, 2023Was cooking the crucial part of developing a human brain size or was its use of Stone Age tools, or whether adding starch-rich USOs (underground storage units) or meat to the diet?
What was the most crucial energy source that provided much-needed energy for the development of the brain size?
The debates are emotional in nature, and not as logical as science needs to be. It is because of our underlying desire to prove to ourselves that meat consumption is natural for human evolution so that we can justify large-scale meat consumption in the modern era. The scientific and archeological data can become a problem in this scenario if data don’t reflect the desirable way of looking at things.
Scientists are not immune to emotional bias. In order to have large-scale meat consumption on a daily basis, the two criteria must be met.
(1) We need to have a viable option for acquiring the meat.
(2) We need to have the physiological ability to digest it.
The first criteria for humans that are not anatomical hunters and are slow and weak and cannot compete with true anatomical hunters are to scavenge for it. That option will not support the calorie requirement and can only be an additional source of calories to a small extent. For the second option, we would need to have fire technology. Subsequently, anything before Homo erectus is excluded. Some scientists believe that even Homo erectus was not capable of controlling the fire. It is a big debate.
Currently, the earliest well-accepted instance of fire-burning in a controlled manner came from Israel’s Qesem Cave 400,000 years ago.
When you don’t hunt and you live on a tree and you need to forage for edible leaves and fruit you have a difficult life. What happened then is a process of natural selection that strongly favors traits that enhance the efficiency of foraging. Hence, as plant foods became increasingly important over time adaptation gradually gave rise to the group of characteristics presently considered the property of primates. Most of these traits are adapted to facilitate the movement and foraging in trees.
For example, adaptation yielded hands well suited for grasping branches and manipulating slender and small fruit and leaves. In order to detect ripe fruits and enable safe moving through arboreal habitats adaptation forced improvement of the optical capabilities (including depth perception, sharpened acuity, and color vision). Good vision is crucial for moving through the three-dimensional space of the forest canopy and quickly determining the appearance of ripe fruits or tiny, young leaves. Carnivorous species do not have full-color vision. They do not need to detect ripe fruits.
Moreover, such environmental pressures also favored the ability to learn and remember the identity and locations of edible plant parts and also to calculate the optimal foraging strategies to save energy thus increasing behavioral flexibility as well. Foraging benefits from the improvement of visual and cognitive skills. As a result, it promoted the development of unusually large brain sizes, a characteristic of primates since their inception.
Eating meat or bone marrow had nothing to do with the development of the larger brain size. Different plant foods will lack the different nutrients we need. For example, one plant may have some but not all amino acids and vitamins at an adequate level, or even if it is nutrient-dense and doesn’t have fiber it may lack energy in the form of carbohydrates (starch and sugar). Mammals that depend primarily on plants for meeting their daily nutritional requirements and are not adapted for one particular plant food source that is in abundance as a consequence must seek out a variety of complementary food sources from a different array of plants.
They have to combine different food types to get all of the nutrients they need. This demand greatly complicates food gathering. It is a tough life, and it is a constant struggle for food and requires constant use of thinking.
Most arboreal hominids and other primates concentrate on ripe fruits on one side and young leaves. They eat other types of food too, but these two are the main ones. Fruits tend to be rich in energy in the form of fructose and relatively low in fiber, but they might not provide all of the essential amino acids and tend to be the rarest of all plant sources. This kind of scarcity complicates things because if in a certain period of the year there are no fruits available. During that time period, the energy requirement is not met, and there is a need for supplementation with different plant sources. Leaves are full of protein and are everywhere, but they are of lower quality meaning there are no carbohydrates in them and we cannot live on them alone, and they tend to be filled with undesirable toxic chemicals.
Because primates are not adapted for digesting fiber they eat young leaves that are softener than the tough old ones that cannot be digested. When trees exhibit seasonal peaks in the production of fruits and young leaves primates have to eat them as much as they can and reliance on a single food choice is not sustainable.
From an evolutionary view, there are two basic strategies for coping with these problems.
One is to increase the efficiency of nutrient extraction from fibrous foods. This is a form of adaptation that we can see in mammals that are grazers.
For hominids in the past and also for primates, and humans fiber essentially go through their stomach unchanged.
Another biological adaptation that can facilitate survival on low-quality plant food is to grow larger over time. When an animal goes larger compared to smaller animals, it will consume greater overall amounts of food to feed its more extensive tissue mass. However, for reasons that science had not been able to entirely explain, the more massive the animal is the fewer calories it needs to sustain itself and attain adequate nourishment. In mathematical terms, larger animals need less energy per unit of body weight. What this means is that larger animals are able to eat less and can eat lower-quality food to meet their energy requirements.
However, growing bigger for primates is not an option because they are arboreal animals. For growing too massive, they risk falling to their death.
Another evolutionary strategy is open to arboreal plant eaters and is more behavioral than biological.
It is a foraging strategy. Because fruits are rare and very sporadically scattered in tropical forests, the strategy requires the implementation of practices that promise to reduce the energy of acquiring these resources. In order to survive the primates must use their brains more and more to form foraging strategies that are sustainable. A good memory would significantly improve the approach. Ability to recall the exact places of plants that produce desirable fruits and when these trees were likely to bear ripe fruits and to remember the precise directions to these trees would improve foraging profitability in energy expenditure sense by lowering search and travel energy costs by enlarging brain capacity to remember and to plan in advance.
In comparison, grazers do not need brain development because their food is all around them and all they need is to lower their head. Reliance on memory and foraging strategies have pushed for the selection and development of a bigger brain size that has a higher ability for storing information. As a group, primates have always depended on selective feeding and on having the brainpower to carry off this strategy successfully.
The growth of the brain size in combination with growth in body size and a decline in teeth size supports the notion of a high-quality diet. And this is an evolutionary adaptation that is universal to all primates in the last 66 Ma. Some have gone far like humans. We have a brain evolved enough to create pure refined white sugar.
Most other plant-eating species, in opposition, have tended to focus heavily on physiological adaptations for better digesting fiber in order to reduce the need to invest energy in searching for high-quality food. Behavioral adaptations, requiring increased brain power, enable certain species to choose high-quality food.
If we look calorie-wise, the brain is the most expensive organ to maintain. It takes over the vast amount of energy from food, roughly 20% at rest in humans. Natural selection is not going to favor the development of a massive brain size if it is not going to get any benefits from enlargement. The appearance of modern humans with big and capable brains occurred because natural selection favored adaptations that focused on the efficiency of foraging. That was the line of evolution that permitted primates to focus their feeding on the most energy-dense, low-fiber diets they could find, and find is a crucial word.
Finding high-quality food in a scarce environment is what created modern humans. It had little to do with eating meat or any other form of energy. A form of energy is of lesser importance than the way that energy is obtained. In other words, if the meat had anything to do with the development of brainpower, then all of the carnivore species on this planet will be colonizing the outer reaches of the galaxy by now. There is no magic nutrient in the meat that was responsible for the rise of human brainpower. Meat is just meat, another energy source.
There is no absolute correlation between meat eating and intelligence. The manner of combining some amount of foraged meat with a predominantly vegan diet did not become a pivotal force in the emergence of modern humans. Also, it is not even correlated to brain size either. There is no particularly strong relationship between brain size and intelligence, with a correlation value between 0.3 and 0.4 out of a possible 1.0. it is the number of neurons in the brain no matter what that brain size is, that counts (Dicke & Roth, 2016). The human brain has the largest number of cortical neurons (about 15 billion), despite the fact that the human brain and cortex are much smaller in size than, for example, those of cetaceans and elephants (with 10–12 billion or even fewer cortical neurons).
References:
- Dicke, U., & Roth, G. (2016). Neuronal factors determining high intelligence. Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences, 371(1685), 20150180. https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2015.0180
- Barr, W. Andrew, et al. “No Sustained Increase in Zooarchaeological Evidence for Carnivory After the Appearance of Homo Erectus.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, vol. 119, no. 5, National Academy of Sciences, Jan. 2022, https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.2115540119.
Related Posts
Do you have any questions about nutrition and health?
I would love to hear from you and answer them in my next post. I appreciate your input and opinion and I look forward to hearing from you soon. I also invite you to follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest for more diet, nutrition, and health content. You can leave a comment there and connect with other health enthusiasts, share your tips and experiences, and get support and encouragement from our team and community.
I hope that this post was informative and enjoyable for you and that you are prepared to apply the insights you learned. If you found this post helpful, please share it with your friends and family who might also benefit from it. You never know who might need some guidance and support on their health journey.
– You Might Also Like –
Learn About Nutrition
Milos Pokimica is a doctor of natural medicine, clinical nutritionist, medical health and nutrition writer, and nutritional science advisor. Author of the book series Go Vegan? Review of Science, he also operates the natural health website GoVeganWay.com
Medical Disclaimer
GoVeganWay.com brings you reviews of the latest nutrition and health-related research. The information provided represents the personal opinion of the author and is not intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The information provided is for informational purposes only and is not intended to serve as a substitute for the consultation, diagnosis, and/or medical treatment of a qualified physician or healthcare provider.NEVER DISREGARD PROFESSIONAL MEDICAL ADVICE OR DELAY SEEKING MEDICAL TREATMENT BECAUSE OF SOMETHING YOU HAVE READ ON OR ACCESSED THROUGH GoVeganWay.com
NEVER APPLY ANY LIFESTYLE CHANGES OR ANY CHANGES AT ALL AS A CONSEQUENCE OF SOMETHING YOU HAVE READ IN GoVeganWay.com BEFORE CONSULTING LICENCED MEDICAL PRACTITIONER.
In the event of a medical emergency, call a doctor or 911 immediately. GoVeganWay.com does not recommend or endorse any specific groups, organizations, tests, physicians, products, procedures, opinions, or other information that may be mentioned inside.
Editor Picks –
Milos Pokimica is a doctor of natural medicine, clinical nutritionist, medical health and nutrition writer, and nutritional science advisor. Author of the book series Go Vegan? Review of Science, he also operates the natural health website GoVeganWay.com
Latest Articles –
Plant Based News
-
This Sweet Potato Grilled Cheese Is A Game Changer – And It’s Vegan
on April 25, 2024
-
This Lentil Stroganoff Is Packed With Plant Protein
on April 24, 2024
-
Is Decaf Coffee Really Unsafe? What You Need To Know
on April 23, 2024
-
How To Make This Gut-Friendly Miso Mushroom Risotto
on April 23, 2024
-
Brazil Is Expanding Its Beef Exports – What Does This Mean For The Amazon?
on April 23, 2024
-
Dairy And Oat Blended Milk Sparks Backlash
on April 23, 2024
-
Try This Spinach Arugula Salad With Candied Pecans And Apples
on April 22, 2024
Top Health News — ScienceDaily
- Solving the riddle of the sphingolipids in coronary artery diseaseon April 24, 2024
Investigators have uncovered a way to unleash in blood vessels the protective effects of a type of fat-related molecule known as a sphingolipid, suggesting a promising new strategy for the treatment of coronary artery disease.
- Tumor cells evade the immune system early on: Newly discovered mechanism could significantly improve cancer immunotherapieson April 24, 2024
Tumors actively prevent the formation of immune responses by so-called cytotoxic T cells, which are essential in combating cancer. Researchers have now uncovered for the first time how this exactly happens. The study provides rationales for new cancer immunotherapies and could make existing treatments more effective.
- Social media can be used to increase fruit and vegetable intake in young peopleon April 24, 2024
Researchers have found that people following healthy eating accounts on social media for as little as two weeks ate more fruit and vegetables and less junk food.
- Low intensity exercise linked to reduced depressionon April 24, 2024
New research has found a significant association between participating in low to moderate intensity exercise and reduced rates of depression.
- Positive effect of midazolam after cardiac arreston April 24, 2024
If a patient is successfully resuscitated after a cardiac arrest and circulation resumes, they are not out of the woods yet. A number of factors can influence whether and how they survive the trauma in the subsequent phase. The administration of the anaesthetic midazolam has a positive effect, as shown by a multicenter study of 571 patients.
- Computer game in school made students better at detecting fake newson April 24, 2024
A computer game helped upper secondary school students become better at distinguishing between reliable and misleading news.
- Researchers unveil PI3K enzyme’s dual accelerator and brake mechanismson April 24, 2024
The enzyme PI3K plays a critical role in cell migration. Scientists have long understood this function. But researchers have recently unveiled that a subunit of this enzyme also has the ability to slam on the breaks to this process.
PubMed, #vegan-diet –
- Psychological differences and similarities between vegans, prospective vegans, and vegetarians. Motivation, knowledge, vegan literacy – and cheeseon April 25, 2024
INTRODUCTION: Although vegan and vegetarian diets and lifestyles differ significantly from each other, among other things, notably in their respective consequences regarding animal welfare and their ecological impact, vegans and vegetarians are often grouped together and usually compared to omnivores in psychological research. Considering that vegans and vegetarians often share similar motives for their lifestyle choices, namely animal and environmental issues, the question arises why similar…
- Vegan grade medium component screening and concentration optimization for the fermentation of the probiotic strain Lactobacillus paracasei IMC 502 using Design of Experimentson April 24, 2024
Lactobacillus paracasei IMC502® is a commercially successful probiotic strain, however, there are no reports that investigate growth medium composition in relation to improved biomass production for this strain. The major outcome of the present study is the design and optimization of a growth medium based on vegan components to be used in the cultivation of Lactobacillus paracasei IMC502®, by using Design of Experiments (DoE). Besides comparing different carbon sources, the use of […]
- What’s cooking? The normalization of meat in YouTube recipe videos consumed by South Asian British Muslimson April 23, 2024
Muslim consumers in the UK eat more meat than the national average. Individuals from ethnic minority backgrounds, particularly South Asian communities, experience poorer health outcomes, including diabetes and cardiovascular disease, associated with meat consumption. According to a YouGov survey, British Pakistani and Bangladeshi consumers use television cookery programs and social media (particularly YouTube) as their main digital sources of dietary information. Against this background, this…
- Nutrition: Micronutrientson April 22, 2024
Micronutrients are nutrients the body needs in small quantities, such as vitamins and minerals. Micronutrient deficiencies can occur when an individual is restricting calorie intake for weight loss or management, not consuming an adequate amount of food to meet energy requirements due to poor appetite or illness, eliminating one or more food groups from the diet on a regular basis, or consuming a diet low in micronutrient-rich foods despite adequate or excessive energy intake. Patient groups […]
- From Tofu to T-Bones: How Vegan and Ketogenic Diets Shape Our Immune Defenseson April 22, 2024
Link et al. conducted a controlled study comparing the impacts of ketogenic and vegan diets on energy intake and immune function in humans. Deep -omics analyses revealed distinct effects of each diet on the immune system, including changes in cell populations and blood transcriptomes indicative of diet-induced shifts between adaptive and innate immunity. The study highlights the potentially significant, rapid impact of diet on immune function and health.
Random Posts –
Featured Posts –
Latest from PubMed, #plant-based diet –
- Mapping the evidence of novel plant-based foods: a systematic review of nutritional, health, and environmental impacts in high-income countriesby Sarah Nájera Espinosa on April 24, 2024
CONCLUSION: If carefully selected, certain NPBFs have the potential to be healthier and nutrient-rich alternatives to ABFs and typically have smaller environmental footprints. More disaggregated categorization of various types of NPBFs would be a helpful step in guiding consumers and key stakeholders to make informed decisions. To enable informed policymaking on the inclusion of NPBFs in dietary transitions as part of a wider net-zero and health strategy, future priorities should include…
- Vegan grade medium component screening and concentration optimization for the fermentation of the probiotic strain Lactobacillus paracasei IMC 502® using Design of Experimentsby Darshankumar Parecha on April 24, 2024
Lactobacillus paracasei IMC502® is a commercially successful probiotic strain, however, there are no reports that investigate growth medium composition in relation to improved biomass production for this strain. The major outcome of the present study is the design and optimization of a growth medium based on vegan components to be used in the cultivation of Lactobacillus paracasei IMC502®, by using Design of Experiments (DoE). Besides comparing different carbon sources, the use of […]
- Metaproteomics and DNA metabarcoding as tools to assess dietary intake in humansby Brianna L Petrone on April 22, 2024
Objective biomarkers of food intake are a sought-after goal in nutrition research. Most biomarker development to date has focused on metabolites detected in blood, urine, skin or hair, but detection of consumed foods in stool has also been shown to be possible via DNA sequencing. An additional food macromolecule in stool that harbors sequence information is protein. However, the use of protein as an intake biomarker has only been explored to a very limited extent. Here, we evaluate and […]
- Mitigating digestive disorders: Action mechanisms of Mediterranean herbal active compoundsby Abdalsalam Kmail on April 22, 2024
This study explores the effects of the Mediterranean diet, herbal remedies, and their phytochemicals on various gastrointestinal conditions and reviews the global use of medicinal plants for common digestive problems. The review highlights key plants and their mechanisms of action and summarizes the latest findings on how plant-based products influence the digestive system and how they work. We searched various sources of literature and databases, including Google Scholar, PubMed, Science…
- Lifestyle Interventions in a Patient Identified as Super-Super Obese With a Body Mass Index of 90.5by Ghadeer Al Ghareeb on April 22, 2024
Obesity is a growing global health concern. Saudi Arabia is experiencing a higher prevalence of obesity compared to the globe. This case report focuses on a 38-year-old female with a body mass index (BMI) of 90.5 kg/m², prediabetes, and obstructive sleep apnea who successfully underwent a lifestyle modification process resulting in remarkable weight loss. The patient’s past unsuccessful attempts at weight loss had left her with a reluctance to try again initially. A multidisciplinary team…
- Effects of supplementing coated methionine in a high plant-protein diet on growth, antioxidant capacity, digestive enzymes activity and expression of TOR signaling pathway associated genes in gibel…by Yingying Du on April 22, 2024
This study explored the impacts of supplementation of different levels of coated methionine (Met) in a high-plant protein diet on growth, blood biochemistry, antioxidant capacity, digestive enzymes activity and expression of genes related to TOR signaling pathway in gibel carp (Carassius auratus gibeilo). A high-plant protein diet was formulated and used as a basal diet and supplemented with five different levels of coated Met at 0.15, 0.30, 0.45, 0.60 and 0.75%, corresponding to final […]