
by Milos Pokimica
Humans evolved for 50 million years from plant-eating mammals. Hunting is not natural hominin activity. The Paleo diet only existed for the last 200,000 years.
Milos Pokimica
A paleo diet is a diet based on foods that humans may have eaten during the Paleolithic Era. The Paleolithic Era lasted between 2.5 million and 10,000 years. Fruits, vegetables, lean meats, fish, eggs, nuts, and seeds are all part of a modern paleo diet. These are foods that people could get in the past by hunting and gathering. It excludes foods that became more common after the advent of small-scale farming after the Neolithic revolution around 10,000 years ago. These foods include grains, legumes, and dairy products.
The goal of a paleo diet is to consume foods that were most likely consumed by early humans. The diet is based on the notion that our genes are not well adapted to modern diets derived from farming. Farming increased the availability of foods such as grains and legumes. It also introduced dairy. Furthermore, farming altered the diets of the animals that people consumed. The idea behind the paleo diet is that these dietary changes have outpaced the human body’s ability to change or adapt. Today, this mismatch is thought to contribute to obesity, diabetes, and heart disease.
And the logic is great by their science is misused to push the agenda.
The problem with the paleo diet is that somehow paleo diet people just dont understand that meat was not a vital source of calories in the paleo period and that the real paleo diet is something completely different than what they are advocating.
Also, human evolution is so far 50 million years long and grains and legumes and especially starchy vegetables had been consumed for a long long time. We are soo well adapted to digesting starch that we could reclassify ourselves as starchivores, and advocating avoidance of corn, peas, and white potatoes is just in the line of mental illness and delusion. All human civilizations in history actually only thrived on starches. All of our ancestors except the aristocracy that had enough money to eat meat were starch-based vegan dieters. Was it rice in Asia or grain in the middle east or corn in Mesoamerica doesn’t matter. All the human civilizations after the Neolithic revolution trived on starch but what paleo people don’t understand most humans before the Neolithic revolution also trived on starch. The only difference is that in the paleo period potatoes were foraged and after the Neolithic revolution potatoes were cultivated.
In general, a paleo diet shares many characteristics with recommended healthy diets. The paleo diet feature is an emphasis on fruits and vegetables and the avoidance of processed foods. The Paleo diet problem is an emphasis on lean meat. Eating large amounts of lean meat is not a real paleo diet. It might be a paleo Neanderthal diet but even that is debunked by some recent studies (Vegan Neanderthals? The truth about the real Neanderthal diet).
What is a real Paleo diet, and the real question is, does it even matter? Evidence suggests that our ancestors, and even we as modern humans, are omnivorous to some extent. We can adapt to different environments to survive. Hominids did not spread across Africa, and then the entire globe, by utilizing just one foraging strategy. We did it by being flexible.
The Paleo period ran from roughly 2.6 million to 10,000 years ago. Practitioners of this type of diet are trying to simulate the conditions of living in Stone Age hunter-gatherer conditions. They are trying to eat a diet that is in line with the pseudo-hunter-gatherer lifestyle and give up modern agricultural inventions and processed foods.
Hunter-gatherers in the Stone age lived by foraging and also by hunting. There is a belief that besides foraging hunting is also a natural human activity and that our natural diet is in line with both hunting and foraging. We must understand the difference between these two. These are two completely different diets.
In order to be a hunter, we will have to be able to hunt in as same as wild cats do. Because we are not adapted for chasing prey, and an average human will not be able to chase down a single squirrel, we will have to depend on some technology. If we do not have the technology, then we depend on food that we can forage.
Logically any form of hunting that will provide a consistent food supply before developing spears or traps will not be sustainable. The truth is that humans and our hominin ancestors are not anatomical hunters. Carnivorous animals are hunters and are adapted to consuming meat.
This means that carnivorous animals are designed for intermittent feeding while we are designed for constant feeding. If we count the energy content of natural foods humans can consume about 900 to 1200 calories in a single sitting which is less than our caloric needs. What this means is that we must eat a couple of times during the day to our full stomach capacity or eat smaller portions throughout the day. Every single day. When carnivores eat, they consume enough energy to last them for a week, and this is important because they will probably not be successful in hunting every day. They can eat carrion no problem. With an acidity of pH1, they have a sterile digestive tract. True omnivores have high resistance filter as well and can eat raw meat with no risk. The acidity of 1 is enough to dissolve not just bones but a metal penny too.
When they kill they do not care about bacteria and viruses, and they will feed on the rotting corpse until they catch something else. For us and our hominin ancestors, the small capacity of our stomach and inability to eat carrion means we cannot retrieve a great amount of energy from a single carcass before it rots and a large amount of energy wasted for catching that prey will put us in deficit.
Humans and Neanderthals even with paleo technology would not be more efficient in hunting than carnivorous animals are. Even in modern times with all of the rifles, hunters are not successful every time they go hunting. Hunting will put us in an energy deficit without preservation techniques.
Only in icy climates hunting large animals will be energetically in surplus because the meat of the carcass will freeze before it goes bad.
That is the reason Neanderthals became omnivores in northern Europe from purely plant-eating lineage.
In Africa, if we go around trying to catch something, and after ten days we are successful, we cannot even consume enough calories in that one meal to replace all of the energy we spent before the meat goes bad.
The only solution is fire. Before the roasting no meat for us. Even the cooked meat does not last for that long. Cooked meat or poultry in the Refrigerator (40 °F or below) has a storage time of 3 to 4 days. At insect-infested hot African savannah, time for consumption before spoiling is much shorter, and roasted leftovers are just baits for some large cats. If we do not catch something today and don’t eat and then do not catch something in 10 days in a row, probably we will be too starving and exhausted to hunt again.
For acquiring the meat on a sustainable basis, we will have to have a way of killing prey that is fast and conditioned to be chased by fast predators. In other words, we will have to have some traps or spears. The first hominin who could have done this is theoretically Homo erectus.

The problem with this is that we do not see any evidence of technology except fire and stone tools. Some scientists have a thesis that Homo erectus used fire to bate, isolate, and kill the animals, but in that scenario, he would have to have much higher intelligence. Using fire for hunting is not using fire, it is using wildfire. Wildfires can spread into large areas and can devastate the habitat and plant food sources and can burn the Homo erectus himself and his cave and half of Africa. If we assume that he was so smart to control the use of wildfire, something even modern firefighters have a problem with, we will have to level the Homo erectus intelligence to a greater extent. If he was capable of doing this, then he would be capable of creating other technologies like traps. That would allow him to spread to cold climates with snow and ice and that was not the case.
Stone tools and animal bone debris does not mean sustainable hunting on a large scale and a real meat-infused omnivorous diet. It means scavenging some meat left behind by big predators if we are lucky and cracking open the bones and head to eat the brain and bone marrow and occasionally killing some of the young and defenseless animals or injured or something in that nature. All of this can happen but on some lucky special occasions and not on large scale daily hunting as Neanderthals did.
If I jump on a gazelle, there would be two options. Gazelle will just run off or kicked me in the gut first and then run off. When we look at human hunting, it always relies on traps, bows, arrows, or other weapons to kill or spears to injure and then persistent hunting until the antelope is exhausted. All methods require the use of technology. Persistence hunting just by itself is not enough because that would mean running for tens of miles for pray and then carrying that pray for tens of miles and if we are lucky not to be seen by another big predator and became meal ourselves. Even if this is possible carrots tend to run slower than rabbits so if there are plant sources around hunting is not an option if we understand the optimal foraging strategies. As soon as this is acquired that species can spread to the cooler climate without abundant plant food sources.
The first hominin to have both conditions right was the Neanderthal and he spread to ice could Europe before us where he hunted large prey. Also, one other thing, even he did not like it. Nobody likes to hunt. We have this kind of romantic view of hunting where we think it is the macho manly thing that we enjoy like we enjoy playing video games. The truth is that it is a most dangerous life-threatening process that exists in nature not just to pray but for a hunter too. If not successful there is a lot of energy loss, and even if it is successful with no injuries, there will be a lot of pain and exhaustion. In the Ice Age in Europe going through five feet of snow is not easy, and there are cold temperatures, and we can die from cold or slip and fall and hit our head or twist an ankle or break bones or fall into the icy water. In summer or in Africa, we could get bitten by a poisonous snake or get in contact with a poisonous plant or fall in quicksand in the swamp, or just get attacked by a wild pack of lions or hyenas or get stung by a swarm of wild bees. That means if we were lucky and didn’t get into the territory of another hominin. Nature at that time was a dangerous and wild place.
If a modern man that knows how to survive in nature with all of our technology loses himself in the wilderness, the possibility for survival for an extended period is zero. In the wild nature of the past possibilities for death are endless. Hunting for hominins and humans is an extreme tactic for survival if nothing else is available. On another hand, if we are foraging and stumble upon a fresh corpse of some animal half-eaten, well lucky us.
Consumption of animal products was insignificant on a scale of forcing adaptation of hominin and human physiology. Our natural diet was based on fruits, flowers, leaves, and in later times vegetables and of tubers, nuts and seeds, and grains. In more recent times (1 Ma) after the invention of cooking, we have eaten grains, legumes, and other more difficult-to-digest tubers, and meat consumption was a couple of percent of total calories.
The first real omnivores were Neanderthals to some extent, not humans. We did not evolve in Europe we came out of Africa and entered Europe and other cold places around a hundred thousand years ago. That is an insignificant time in evolution.
The only way of hunting where metrics can work is in a larger type of community of modern Humans or Neanderthals with labor division, but this requires high cognitive capability with advanced social structures and hierarchy with language, technology like fire, spears, clothing, and so on.
So how will metrics work? It goes something like this.
A small group of hunters will go hunting. Not all of the men just small groups. Maybe one group or two depending on the size of the village. If the village is bigger more can go. They will go out to check the traps to see if anything smaller is trapped and then they will go hunting for something bigger like Antelope. Hunting can be directly killing or persistent hunting or something third. However, where the metrics work is that they will not eat the meat, they will bring it to the village for everyone to eat. Therefore, even if they themselves expended much of their energy and more than they can consume in a single sitting the entire village is in surplus because that antelope will not last enough to get spoiled it will be eaten immediately by the entire village. In return when they are not successful hunters would eat regular food gathered from foraging by other tribe members.
This is a complex social structure. When we look at African tribes of today like the Kalahari San people, for example, we can see something similar. Using poisons men can kill large and fast animals. Women have clever ways of rendering low-quality plant foods edible. Although archaeology suggests that the strategies used by San people are only a few thousand years old and are somewhat different from the strategies used by more ancient hunter-gatherers still it is on a similar line.
When anthropologists look at this, they will see a pattern that lasts 250,000 years to the time of the Neolithic revolution, and the conclusion would be that this behavior is natural and that we are omnivorous as bears. And you will have thousands of books everywhere about the paleo diet representing this short time period in human evolution as a basic human state. And the big question is how normal is this actually?
Our physiology evolved from small plant-eating mammals for more than 50 million years, and we had been using this hunting strategy for 200,000 years. Does our body physiology really cope reasonably well with a larger quantity of meat?
Russell Henry Chittenden, the father of American biochemistry, wrote back in 1904:
“We hear on all sides widely divergent views regarding the needs of the body, as to the extent and character of food requirements, contradictory statements as to the relative merits of animal and vegetable foods; indeed, there is a significant lack of agreement regarding many of the fundamental questions that continuously arise in any consideration of the nutrition of the human body.”
Sources:
Passages selected from a book: “Go Vegan? Review of Science: Part 1” [Milos Pokimica]
Related Posts
- Facebook19
- Pinterest1
- Reddit1
- Blogger
- Gmail1
- Viber1
- Love This
- Click me for More
- Facebook Messenger
- Skype
- Digg
- Del
- Tumblr
- VKontakte
- Flattr
- Buffer
- Odnoklassniki
- Meneame
- Amazon
- Yahoo Mail
- AOL
- Newsvine
- HackerNews
- Evernote
- MySpace
- Mail.ru
- Viadeo
- Line
- Comments
- Yummly
- SMS
- Telegram
- Kakao
- LiveJournal
- Yammer
- Edgar
- Fintel
- Instapaper
- Copy Link
- Mix
- 50shares
From The Same Category
You Might Also Like
Vegan Neanderthals? The truth about the real Neanderthal diet
Tap water toxicity- Risk assessment
China study- The vegan argument
Coca-Cola Company- Historical Review
EMF radiation (electromagnetic radiation) exposure- Does 5G pose health risks?
Vitamin D deficiency- The optimization strategies
Glycogen depletion- How not to exercise
Intermittent Fasting vs Calorie Restriction- Is there a difference?
Micronutrient deficiency in Standard American Diet- The optimization strategies
Detoxification – A Scientific Review

Medical Disclaimer
GoVeganWay.com brings you reviews of the latest nutrition and health-related research. The information provided represents the personal opinion of the author and is not intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. The information provided is for informational purposes only and is not intended to serve as a substitute for the consultation, diagnosis, and/or medical treatment of a qualified physician or healthcare provider.NEVER DISREGARD PROFESSIONAL MEDICAL ADVICE OR DELAY SEEKING MEDICAL TREATMENT BECAUSE OF SOMETHING YOU HAVE READ ON OR ACCESSED THROUGH GoVeganWay.com
NEVER APPLY ANY LIFESTYLE CHANGES OR ANY CHANGES AT ALL AS A CONSEQUENCE OF SOMETHING YOU HAVE READ IN GoVeganWay.com BEFORE CONSULTING LICENCED MEDICAL PRACTITIONER.
In the event of a medical emergency, call a doctor or 911 immediately. GoVeganWay.com does not recommend or endorse any specific groups, organizations, tests, physicians, products, procedures, opinions, or other information that may be mentioned inside.
Around The Web,
Medicine
Around The Web,
Medicine
-
A high-throughput screening assay for small molecule inhibitors of the antigen aminopeptidase ERAP1
by News Medical Life Science News Feed on January 28, 2023
The January 2023 issue of SLAS Discovery contains a collection of four full-length articles and one technical brief covering cancer research, high-throughput screening (HTS) assay development and other drug discovery exploration.
-
Activated neutrophils can become potent cancer fighters
by News Medical Life Science News Feed on January 28, 2023
Elevated levels of immune cells, called neutrophils, in tumors have been associated with poor outcomes in people with cancer.
-
Jaypirca Approved for Relapsed/Refractory Mantle Cell Lymphoma
by Diana Ernst, RPh (Medical Bag) on January 27, 2023
As a noncovalent inhibitor of BTK, pirtobrutinib is able to reestablish BTK inhibition in patients previously treated with covalent BTK inhibitors.
-
FDA Approval Updates Enjaymo Indication for Cold Agglutinin Disease
by Diana Ernst, RPh (Medical Bag) on January 27, 2023
Enjaymo is an immunoglobulin G subclass 4 monoclonal antibody.
-
Is At-Home Teeth Whitening Safe?
by Harmeet Gurm (Medical News Bulletin) on January 27, 2023
Medical News Bulletin – Daily Medical News, Health News, Clinical Trials And Clinical Research, Medical Technology, Fitness And Nutrition News–In One Place The desire to whiten teeth has existed for over a century, with hydrogen peroxide being the go-to whitening agent.1 In cosmetic dentistry, teeth whitening is one of the most popular practices.1 Hydrogen peroxide is used in dental offices […]
-
Keytruda Approved as Adjuvant Treatment for Stage IB, II, or IIIA NSCLC
by Diana Ernst, RPh (Medical Bag) on January 27, 2023
The approval was based on data from the KEYNOTE-091 trial.
-
Various Factors Affect the Pancreatic Microbiome Following Pancreatic Surgery
by Kwamesha Joseph (Medical Bag) on January 27, 2023
Researchers examined the relationship between the pancreatic microbiome and patient characteristics as well as the duodenal microbiome.
-
Childhood, Adolescent Cancers Linked to Higher Risk of Major Psychiatric Disorders
by Erin Clancy (Medical Bag) on January 27, 2023
Compared with the general population, survivors of childhood and adolescent cancers have an increased risk of 6 major psychiatric disorders.
-
Gepirone Under Review for Major Depressive Disorder
by Steve Duffy (Medical Bag) on January 27, 2023
Exxua (previously named Travivo) is a novel oral serotonin 1A receptor agonist.
-
Emzahh Gets FDA Approval for Pregnancy Prevention
by Diana Ernst, RPh (Medical Bag) on January 27, 2023
Emzahh is an AB-rated generic equivalent of Ortho Micronor.
-
Researchers identify an unexpected driver of cancer immunotherapy resistance
by News Medical Life Science News Feed on January 27, 2023
A research team from the LKS Faculty of Medicine, the University of Hong Kong (HKUMed) has identified an unexpected driver of cancer immunotherapy resistance: the harmful effect of chronic Type I Interferon signaling on tumor-killing CD8+ T cells.
-
Survey: Trust in genetics increased significantly during the pandemic
by News Medical Life Science News Feed on January 27, 2023
A survey of over 2,000 British adults finds that trust in genetics is high and went up significantly during the pandemic. It also finds that there is a hunger for more coverage of genetics.
-
Researchers discover a key role played by ch-TOG protein in the initiation of microtubule assembly
by News Medical Life Science News Feed on January 27, 2023
Microtubules are cellular fibres that are part of the skeleton of the cell, termed cytoskeleton. They ensure that cells maintain their shape, carry out their functions, and divide.
-
FDA Revises Evusheld EUA Halting Use of the COVID-19 Therapy for Now
by Diana Ernst, RPh (Medical Bag) on January 26, 2023
Recent data show that the product is unlikely to be active against currently circulating SARS-CoV-2 variants.
Latest from PubMed,
#plant-based diet
-
Phosphate Intake and Removal in Predominantly Vegetarian Patients on Twice-Weekly Hemodialysis
by Namrata Sarvepalli Rao on January 27, 2023
-
Self-care and lifestyle interventions of complementary and integrative medicine during the COVID-19 pandemic-A cross-sectional study
by Michael Jeitler on January 26, 2023
-
Use of male-to-female sex reversal as a welfare scoring system in the protandrous farmed gilthead sea bream (Sparus aurata)
by Paul G Holhorea on January 26, 2023
-
The effect of diet quality on the risk of developing gestational diabetes mellitus: A systematic review and meta-analysis
by Xiaoxia Gao on January 26, 2023
-
The Climate Change Challenge: How to get research into society through an online workshop
by Laura Müller on January 26, 2023
-
Associations of dietary patterns with obesity and weight change for adults aged 18-65 years: Evidence from the China Health and Nutrition Survey (CHNS)
by Yang Chen on January 25, 2023
-
Two a posteriori dietary patterns are associated with risks of hyperuricemia among adults in less-developed multiethnic regions in Southwest China
by Xinyu Wu on January 25, 2023
-
Buffalo milk and rumen fluid metabolome are significantly affected by green feed
by G Neglia on January 25, 2023
-
Metabolic and nutritional biomarkers in adults consuming lacto-ovo vegetarian, vegan and omnivorous diets in Spain. A cross-sectional study
by Elena García-Maldonado on January 23, 2023
-
Protein quality as a complementary functional unit in life cycle assessment (LCA)
by G A McAuliffe on January 23, 2023
-
NEW Soul in the neighborhood-reach and effectiveness of a dissemination and implementation feasibility study
by John A Bernhart on January 23, 2023
-
Interaction between genetics and inulin affects host metabolism in rainbow trout fed a sustainable all plant-based diet
by Jep Lokesh on January 23, 2023
-
Adherence to the EAT-Lancet diet, genetic susceptibility, and risk of type 2 diabetes in Swedish adults
by Shunming Zhang on January 22, 2023
-
Risks and Benefits of Different Dietary Patterns in CKD
by Shivam Joshi on January 22, 2023
-
Plant-based and vegetarian diets: an overview and definition of these dietary patterns
by Shila Minari Hargreaves on January 21, 2023
Latest Articles
Podcast of the day…
Plant Based News
-
Dublin Bus Adverts Promoting Veganism Spark Backlash From Politicians
on January 27, 2023
-
192-Year-Old Luxury Retailer Harvey Nichols Finally Bans Fur
on January 27, 2023
-
Cauldron Foods Is Now A Fully Vegan Brand
on January 27, 2023
-
‘The Last Of Us’ Star Bella Ramsey Is An Outspoken Advocate For Veganism
on January 27, 2023
-
‘Put Zebra Meat On The Menu in South Africa,’ Say Scientists
on January 27, 2023
-
LinkedIn Headquarters Goes Mostly Plant-Based To Reduce Carbon Footprint
on January 26, 2023
-
‘Pet’ Tiger Killed After Escaping Enclosure And Attacking Man In South Africa
on January 26, 2023
Top Health News — ScienceDaily
- Milk’s packaging influences its flavoron January 27, 2023
The dairy industry strives to preserve the quality and safety of milk products while maintaining the freshest possible taste for consumers. To date, the industry has largely focused on packaging milk in light-blocking […]
- New test could detect Alzheimer’s disease 3.5 years before clinical diagnosison January 27, 2023
New research has established a blood-based test that could be used to predict the risk of Alzheimer’s disease up to 3.5 years before clinical diagnosis.
- New technology may help inform brain stimulationon January 27, 2023
Researchers are a step closer to unravelling the mystery of brain activity to better understand the outcomes of deep brain stimulation (DBS).
- Researchers map the effects of dietary nutrients on diseaseon January 27, 2023
Researchers have created a tool to predict the effects of different diets on both cancerous cells and healthy cells in mice. Their work could help disentangle the subtle metabolic changes associated with different types […]
- Gum infection may be a risk factor for heart arrhythmia, researchers findon January 27, 2023
Periodontitis, a gum disease, can lead to a litany of dental issues from bad breath to bleeding and lost teeth. Now, researchers have found that it could be connected to even more severe problems elsewhere in the body […]
- Study shows FDA-approved TB regimen may not work against the deadliest form of TB due to multidrug-resistant strainson January 27, 2023
Findings in animal models show that a U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved antibiotic regimen for multidrug-resistant (MDR) tuberculosis (TB) may not work for TB meningitis.
- Prairie voles without oxytocin receptors can bond with mates and youngon January 27, 2023
The vital role of oxytocin — the ‘love hormone’ — for social attachments is being called into question. More than forty years of pharmacological and behavioral research has pointed to oxytocin receptor signaling as an […]

PubMed, #vegan-diet
-
Metabolic and nutritional biomarkers in adults consuming lacto-ovo vegetarian, vegan and omnivorous diets in Spain. A…
on January 23, 2023
-
NEW Soul in the neighborhood-reach and effectiveness of a dissemination and implementation feasibility study
on January 23, 2023
-
Comparison of sensitivity to taste and astringency stimuli among vegans and omnivores
on January 22, 2023
-
Protective Effect of Vegan Microbiota on Liver Steatosis Is Conveyed by Dietary Fiber: Implications for Fecal…
on January 21, 2023
-
Plant-based and vegetarian diets: an overview and definition of these dietary patterns
on January 21, 2023